That Sinking Feeling
Picture yourself at your desk at work. You open your email inbox and sitting right at the top is a fresh email from your boss, your boss that you haven’t been getting along with for a while. The subject line reads, “Regarding your work.”
It leaps off the screen to your attention. Without looking, you know what it is–your boss rarely sends you friendly chit-chat. In rushes that sinking feeling…
Destructive Criticism
I hate moments like that. Getting criticized by a difficult person can be rough. Whether it’s in an email, over the phone, or face to face, criticism can be disarming and upsetting–even if it’s delivered gently. When it comes from an unfriendly source on a regular basis, it can be downright stressful.
Several of my job-hating readers have told me that the single greatest cause of dissatisfaction at their job has been an overly critical boss or a few vulturous co-workers. Sometimes the very culture of the workplace can be defined by unfriendly competition and tearing one another down.
Since even my job-loving readers struggle with accepting criticism, let’s just call it a nearly universal problem.
Five Little Steps
This morning I read a great little post with some good pointers on this subject over at Water Cooler Wisdom. It is one of my favorite blogs, and it happens to be written by one of my favorite bloggers. Her name is Alexandra Levit, and she’s such a nice person, I think from now on I’ll refer to her as Alexandra the Great on this blog (Alexandra, if you hate that, please let me know).
Whether the criticism is valid or not, her 5 tips should help you defuse that sinking feeling and take appropriate action:
- Depersonalize the criticism (repeat to yourself, “it’s a specific behavior that’s the problem, not me as a person”).
- Restate the comments for clarification (“what I heard was that this behavior is not acceptable”).
- Seek guidance (“How could I do that differently? What change would be appropriate?”).
- Process the input (ask yourself, “Is this criticism valid? Am I willing to make the change to eliminate the contention?”).
- Review your progress/seek follow up (“I’m working hard to bring about the change we talked about. Do you have any suggestions for what else I can do?”).
Do yourself a favor and read the original post. There are other good thoughts that you should find helpful, including a pointer on handling unfair criticism.
What other tips do you find helpful for processing criticism?
If you enjoy reading this blog, why not tip the author?
6 responses so far ↓
1 Melissa // Jul 24, 2007 at 4:29 pm
Good post. Criticism really can be helpful, and like you said, it’s important to try to approach it as an opportunity to improve, not as a personal attack (although that can be very difficult). There are also times when the criticism is simply hurtful– unfounded or over-emphasized. It’s important to be able to tell if it is worth worrying over or not. Advice on how to do that?
2 Chuck Westbrook // Jul 25, 2007 at 8:07 am
Thanks Melissa.
You should check out Alexandra’s blog for a little more depth on the subject.
My take on that is to ask a bunch of my friends, “Do I do this?” or if strictly work-related, some co-workers that I trust.
3 Heath // Jul 25, 2007 at 1:36 pm
Thanks for the referral to Alexandra’s blog. I visited and was impressed. I think all managers should use those five points as a reference when giving criticism and it could serve as a mantra when receiving criticism.
4 Chuck Westbrook // Jul 25, 2007 at 1:47 pm
@Heath– You’re very welcome. Her site and my site are good compliments to one another, I think.
Her advice is pragmatic and professional, and I once again recommend her blog to anyone looking to better their career savvy.
5 Eric B // Aug 3, 2007 at 1:24 pm
Think of it this way: It is usually management’s failure if they can not help or motivate their employees succeed.
6 Sally // Jun 9, 2008 at 3:11 am
I am suffering from work related depression and the opening comments aboud work performance hit hard.
I went through some mental congnitive exercises and now the pain is not so bad. Its really hard not to take things personally and see yourself as a failure.
Leave a Comment